While at Harvard University, Jeff Barcy’s activities included being a member of the Varsity Wrestling Team. Before that, while in high school, he was co-captain of his wrestling team.

He went undefeated in high school throughout his regular senior season. He achieved over 100 wins during his high school wrestling career. This included a trip to the Nationals in Iowa. At Harvard University, he competed at the NCAA level on the university’s varsity wrestling team.